#FascistLivesMatter or Why Historical Revisionism Cannot Be Redacted From Any AltRight Platform

4 posts

Thomas777
Yes - The Cold War presented a conceptual/dialectical moral condundrum for America that was never adequately resolved; Ernst Nolte wrote extensively on this, focusing his analysis specifically on the (then current) American war in Southeast Asia, a conflict in which a Clausewitz-ian victory metric was grotesquely (and callously) distilled down to running tallies of corpses and the efficiency with which the American and allied war machine was manufacturing Enemy corpses. Of course, in declared free fire zones and the like ''enemy'' persons became defined as any person present in a geographic territory that was claimed to have been assigned an essential, strategic value by the Communists; and physical presence in these 'strategic hamlets' was said to permit a reasonable inference that the persons in question were bearers of the Enemy idea/animating principle (i.e. Marxist-Leninism). It wasn't lost on Nolte that these practices weren't qualitatively different (in 'moral' terms) than the practice of corralling and/or annihilating Bolshevik-sympathetic populations in the East by the General Government or the SS/SD in the Greater German Reich.

America largely resolved these contradictions by abandoning the Truman Doctrine - in favor of creating client states (which had the added benefit of being a huge profit source to the American arms industry) and by suggesting that the USSR had somehow abandoned the agreed-upon mission of the Nuremberg System - this is what really underlay the Helsinki Accords (why the DDR and the USSR put a premium on such political theater I mean) and why Gorbachev was so resistant to demands by men in the Soviet security apparatus to enforce the Breznhev Doctrine as the internal situation became critical in 1989 - the conceptual/intellectual climate of 1949-1989 remained grounded in the ideology of Anti-Fascism; and the Eastern Bloc and the United States/NATO busily set about accusing one another of behaving in a demonstrably ''Fascist'' manner each and every time the Cold War actually became ''hot'' in various contested theaters.

Had World War 3 happened, Hitler would have remained the model for Satan - the proximate cause of the conflict would have been identified as rogue elements in the US and Soviet regimes (Fascist elements, in other words) succeeding in their evil machinations by provoking a world war.
Thomas777

The Left actually won the Cold War - Paul Gottfried is the only somewhat high profile political theorist who makes this point regularly as far as I know.

Jude
Yes, he often makes a point of comparing how the US criticized the USSR in the early Cold War compared to the later Cold War. The criticism went from Soviet godlessness in the 1950s to the Soviet suppression of religious/sexual/ethnic minorities by the 1980s.
RedHand
This was mentioned in an American history course I took last year, took me by surprise as I hadn't really considered this angle before. U.S government also tried piggybacking desegregation efforts onto the post-War manoeuvres against the U.S.S.R.

This is the standard line on university campuses right now, among tutors and the student Far Left.

Source: current student