← Autodidact Archive · Original Dissent · Hilaire Belloc

Which Philosophers do you agree with most?

Thread ID: 10707 | Posts: 16 | Started: 2003-10-24

Wayback Archive


Hilaire Belloc [OP]

2003-10-24 07:40 | User Profile

[url]http://www.selectsmart.com/FREE/select.php?client=PhilosophyGuys[/url]

My results:

1 Aquinas

2 Augustine

3 Plato

4 Aristotle

5 Kant

6 Nietzsche

7 Sextus Empiricus

8 Hume

9 Protagoras


friedrich braun

2003-10-24 07:49 | User Profile

1 Nietzsche

2 Hume

3 Kant

.

4 Sextus Empiricus

5 Aristotle

6 Protagoras

7 Aquinas

8 Plato

9 Augustine

At home, in my office, I have a giant portrait of the great Saxon philosopher, Nietzsche, on the wall. I also a have a heavy, bronze bust (cost me a little fortune) of Voltaire.


Anarch

2003-10-24 10:20 | User Profile

1 Aquinas

2 Nietzsche

3 Hume

4 Augustine

5 Aristotle

6 Plato

7 Kant

8 Sextus Empiricus

9 Protagoras

Aquinas and Nietzsche... hmmm...


Texas Dissident

2003-10-24 19:40 | User Profile

No Kierkegaard?

A person can be a great logician and become immortal on account of his merit, yet prostitute himself by assuming that the logical is the existential, and that the principle of contradiction is abrogated in existence because it is undeniably abrogated in logic, while in fact existence is the very separation which prevents the flow of pure logic. Hegel may very well be world-historical as a thinker, but one thing he has clearly lacked: he was not brought up in the Christian religion, or only moderately. For just as the person brought up to believe in God learns that, even if every misfortune fell to his lot in life and he never had a happy day, he must simply hold out, so also the person brought up in Christianity learns to regard this as eternal truth and to look on every difficulty as simply a spiritual trial. But so far from Hegel's concept of Christianity bearing the imprint of this childlike primitivity of inwardness, his treatment of faith - e. g. of what it is to believe - is nothing but pure silliness [corrected from "stupidity"]. I am not afraid to say this. If I presumed to say of the most simple-minded man alive that he is too stupid to become a Christian, that would be a matter between myself and God, and woe unto me! But to say this of Hegel remains only a matter between myself and Hegel, and a few Hegelians at most, for the stupidity is of another kind; and to say this is no blasphemy against the God who created man in his image, and consequently against every man, and against the God who took human form in order to save all, the most simple-minded as well.


FadeTheButcher

2003-10-24 20:17 | User Profile

1 Nietzsche

2 Sextus Empiricus

3 Protagoras

4 Kant

5 Hume

6 Augustine

7 Aristotle

8 Aquinas

9 Plato


Bardamu

2003-10-24 20:40 | User Profile

No Charles Bukowski?


Franco

2003-10-24 21:35 | User Profile

JudeoChristian: "Uhhhh....Spinoza."

Heh, heh.

:jester:


Robbie

2003-10-24 23:31 | User Profile

[B]1.Kant[/B] 2. Aquinas 3. Augustine 4. Plato 5. Hume 6. Aristotle 7. Protagoras 8. Nietzsche 9. Sextus Empiricus


Ruffin

2003-10-25 00:16 | User Profile

1 Augustine

2 Aquinas

3 Aristotle

4 Plato

5 Hume

6 Kant

7 Protagoras

8 Sextus Empiricus

9 Nietzsche

I guess I think (almost) alphabetically.


Ausonius

2003-10-25 02:17 | User Profile

  1. Aquinas
  2. Augustine
  3. Plato
  4. Aristotle
  5. Hume
  6. Kant
  7. Nietzsche
  8. Sextus Empiricus
  9. Protagoras

Faust

2003-10-27 15:07 | User Profile

My results:

1Aquinas

2Augustine

3Aristotle

4Plato

5Kant

6Hume

7Protagoras

8Sextus Empiricus

9Nietzsche


Enkidu

2003-10-28 01:08 | User Profile

  1. Pythagoras

  2. Parmenides (Very little known about him, One philosophical poem, and one of Plato’s plays about him --- He wrote a good refutation of Atheism, that I needed to read. His other idea, that nothing moves, everything is fixed --- naaah! His rating with me is kind of personal)

  3. Whoever wrote the Bhagavad-Gita ( I’d put it higher, but someone might think that I’m Rban sneaking back.)

  4. Lao Tzu

  5. Plato

  6. Collectively, a bunch of Sufi philosophers

Enkidu

I just remembered, there was a Bishop in the early church: 7. Pelagius


Ragnar

2003-10-28 01:28 | User Profile

[QUOTE=Bardamu]No Charles Bukowski?[/QUOTE]

Yeah. And no Eric Hoffer. Phooey. :crybaby:


Angler

2003-10-28 11:56 | User Profile

My results:

1 Augustine

2 Aquinas

3 Kant

4 Aristotle

5 Plato

6 Hume

7 Nietzsche

8 Sextus Empiricus

9 Protagorus

It's somewhat surprising to me that Augustine came out on top, as I disagree with much of his theology.


TexasAnarch

2003-11-06 16:35 | User Profile

Gurdjieff


Mentzer

2003-11-20 04:09 | User Profile

1 Nietzsche

2 Hume