I watched Midnight in Paris in a small art theater populated by SWPLs, and the experience was like watching an episode of Jeopardy (category: 20s culture) with the entire cast of NPR. HEY LOOK, THAT'S ZELDA FITZGERALD screeched some scrawny hipster in a mashup retro t-shirt two rows behind me;
t
hat's a reference to The Exterminating Angel
whispered a tubby beardo two seats to my left. Unpleasant to say the least. Yes, we get it, you know the references, congratulations you've taken a college humanities course once in your pathetic dead-end life, now shut the fuck up please.
It was far from Allen's best. The fiancee's parents were obnoxiously unlikable caricatures of what Allen thinks rich conservatives are like, and the 'tea party' reference will expire faster than the gallon of milk I'm drinking as I write this review. Hemingway's dialogue made me cringe. Owen Wilson acted mopey and passive-aggressive, which is to say he was an excellent Woody replacement. The film's sentimentality is over-indulgent and the moral empty and facile (people's lives were just as shit then as they are now; nostalgia prevents us from living in the present). Adrien Brody's disgusting jewnose is shown on-screen (disguised as Salvador Dali). Rachel McAdams is a cunt.
Despite these negatives, even Allen's weaker films are better than the majority of the utter shit that Hollywood produces. To his credit Allen eschews a rigorous explanation of how the protagonist was able to time travel, blending fantasy and reality to give the whole film a magical realist vibe ala
Pleasantville
. A lesser director would have concocted some ridiculous theory, probably involving Very Complicated Sciency stuff, or perhaps a magic substance of some sort. The movie is visually gorgeous -- you can tell Allen really does love Paris's scenery -- and there's some decent humor in the Curb Your Enthusiasm vein (the earring scene in particular). I give it a tepid 4.5 out of 10 stars.